Redemption Rights vs Physical Ownership — What You Get
Owning a token for a vaulted card and owning the card are not the same thing — and the distance between them is the whole game. This explainer separates the two rights collectors routinely conflate: what the token is and what you can demand from the vault.
Two rights, not one#
| Right | What it means | Where it lives |
|---|---|---|
| Token ownership | You hold the on-chain record — tradable instantly, publicly proven | The blockchain |
| Redemption right | The platform will ship you the physical item on request — if its docs promise that | The platform’s terms |
A token without a redemption right is a receipt for a picture. A redemption right without a named vault, a process, and a fee schedule is a marketing sentence. Check both independently.
What “redeem” really does#
On the documented vault platforms, redemption is a one-way door:
- Courtyard — redemption requires identity verification (KYC; the platform itself requires users 18+ or able to form a binding contract per its ToS), burns the token permanently, and ships the physical slab at-cost via FedEx from a Delaware vault. Trade the token or hold the card — not both.
- Phygitals — “claiming” retires the digital token and ships the physical card from its US vault partners (the platform requires users 18+ or the age of majority per its ToS); notably, its documentation states the collector retains legal title to the item throughout — the token is a title-record, not a licence.
The mechanism matters more than the promise: burn-on-redeem (token destroyed) vs claim-and-retire (token delisted) both end your on-chain position, but the legal-title question — who owns the item while it’s vaulted — is separate and is what actually protects you if the platform fails.
The title question (the one that decides what happens on shutdown)#
If the platform’s documentation says title passed to you at purchase, the vaulted item is your property sitting in their warehouse — you have a real claim even if the company dies. If title stays with the platform until redemption, you’re an unsecured creditor holding a promise. This distinction — not the token, not the vault’s brand — is what decides the outcome in a platform shutdown.
Before you buy a vaulted token#
- [ ] Redemption process documented: cost, KYC, shipping scope, timeframe — and whether it reaches Australia at a sane price
- [ ] Legal title: platform docs state you own the vaulted item
- [ ] Vault named: operator and location identified, not just “secure facility”
- [ ] Burn mechanics clear: you know the token dies on redemption
- [ ] If any box can’t be checked from official docs — that’s unverified, and our registry records it as such
Bottom line: the token proves you hold a record; the redemption terms prove you can convert it into the item; the title terms prove the item was ever yours. Verify all three — they fail independently. Registry profiles carry redemption and custody_model fields exactly so you don’t have to dig this out of terms-of-service yourself: the registry.